Ramadan Versus Tromsø, Norway
Ramadan (or Ramzan) is the Islamic month of fasting, in which Muslims do not eat or drink anything from true dawn until sunset. Fasting, according to Islamic theology, is meant to teach the person patience, sacrifice and humility. During Ramzan, Muslims offer more prayer than usual.
This Islamic observance takes place during the ninth month of the Islamic calendar; the month in which the Qur’an was “revealed” to the Prophet Muhammad. The Islamic calendar is a lunar calendar used by Muslims everywhere to determine the proper day on which to celebrate Islamic holy days and festivals such as Ramzan. It is a lunar calendar having 12 lunar months in a year of about 354 days. Because this lunar year is about 11 days shorter than the solar year, Islamic holy days, although celebrated on fixed dates on the Islamic calendar, usually shift 11 days earlier each successive solar year.
Another fact. Tromsø is a northern city in Norway with a population of about 70,000 people. At that latitude however, hundreds of thousands of people live across Russia, Canada, Sweden, Alaska and the likes. Norway is popularly known as the Land of the Midnight Sun. Tromsø goes without the sun for two months or 60 days between 21 November and 21 January, and has the midnight sun looming for about two months and eight days, or a total of 68 days.
So the question that arises is, since there are about 60 days of darkness and daylight at times in Tromsø, and Muslims are supposed to fast (including not drinking anything, not even swallowing one’s own saliva) from dawn until sunset, what would a Muslim living in Tromsø do, if Ramzan fell in such a season?
Did the Islamic God really not know that there are places in the world where days last as long as two months? Surely, it would be absurd for someone to fast this long. Did God not know this?
Of course, the reason is simpler. Like any other religion, Islam grew out of the imagination of the human mind. Initially, in light of the prevalent social order, religion was even progressive. But it was influenced by the material world around them. It was based on the knowledge that existed at that time. Islam originated and evolved into its current form in what is now known as Saudi Arabia and surrounding states. No one really knew that the lengths of days differed across regions then. They did not even know the Earth was not flat, or that the Sun did not revolve around the Earth.
This contradiction is among the many that show the Human angle to the claimed divine and supernatural.
Judaism, like any other religion would, also faced the same problem. All modern religions of the world sprung up in Asia around 0 B.C., give or take a few hundred years (Ancient religions such as Hinduism, the Egyptian, Greek, Roman and Norse ones are older and have more diverse beginnings). But Jews were able to tackle this problem when Judaism reached such Northern communities. They gave rise to a body of Jewish law in the Polar Regions, which attempt to deal with the special challenges of adhering to the Mitzvah in such conditions. When Islam finally reaches the Polar Regions (the surety of the statement is intentional to bring about the irony), I’m sure some Islamic leaders will stand up and create a new set of rules to suit the situation.
But in doing so, they would miss the important point: religion is manmade, and religious knowledge is limited in general to those who thought up of them, and to the time they thought up of them. God is not a divine being whose say we have to follow, “He” is merely a figment of human imagination.
[Disclaimer: In light of being pointed out otherwise by some non-religious agnostics, I mention here that “God” above refers to the ones that religions speak of.]
——————————————————————————————————————-
Also Read: The Science of Ghosts









Good observation Siddharth.
“I’m sure some Islamic leaders will stand up and create a new set of rules to suit the situation”
yes they can, as long as someone doesn’t call them apostates for changing Allah’s laws and decide to chop their head off.
What if those who modify the laws to put in the exceptions are those who usually call for the chopping of heads? They will probably be taken aback by the inherent loophole and patch it up. Afterall, pregnant women, old people etc do have relaxations. In fact, even travellers do . There probably will be an interpretation of this and a relaxation given to resident of polar regions.
Hey, religion has its ways of overcoming such minor hurdles! It’s open to interpretation afterall. :P
Islam does make things easy for it followers when need be,
So exception in such situations can be made.
PS : I do not know if your choice of Tromso was deliberate, but if I am not wrong, it does host the world most north-ly mosque, which means that the city does have a Muslim population, need to ask them what they do :)
Yes Islamic theology is indeed flexible and according to many historians, it is the cause why Islamic texts is used and misused so very rampantly.
Tromso was deliberate because it was one of the Northern most cities with a relatively large population, hence I presumed it had the best of chances in the region for other cultures to grow in. Turns out I guessed right! That was news to me, Khalil, thanks! I think I’m going to find out more.
Thanks again.
JUNE 2009. New articles ??
And I like this article. I agree all religions are man-made and open to MIS-interpretation. And of course also open to making rules for the exceptions and exceptions tot he rules. Basically religion is about empowering the middlemen between gods and their devotees.
Hi IHM!
Yes I was supposed to begin putting up new articles starting last month, but have got really busy! I am editing a book that would be published soon. Also doing a project on NREGA. That keeps me really busy.
“Basically religion is about empowering the middlemen between gods and their devotees.” Yes that pretty much sums up what religion is all about! Well said!
Hi IHM!
Yes I was supposed to begin putting up new articles starting last month, but have got really busy! I am editing a book that would be published soon. Also doing a project on NREGA. That keeps me really busy.
“Basically religion is about empowering the middlemen between gods and their devotees.” Yes that pretty much sums up what religion is all about! Well said!
Hei,
I live in Norway and i have spent some time in nord-norge which is actually northern part. So for me i guess you have limited aspect about religion islam and rules followed in nord-norge. One thing is that it is allowed to adjust Ramadan timings according to some normal timings near to your neighbour country.plus in nord-norge they follow timings implemented in oslo.So its easy to handle it over there so don’t take tension what God thought and what not.
Hi!
Yes, Sara, I do happen to have only a limited knowledge about the region. But I would not say the same about Islam, which I have studied about quite a bit (though of course, I am not a Koranic scholar, so don’t expect a barrage of verses from me).
My point has been strengthened by your illustration, which is an inadvertant outcome of you comment. Adjusting Ramadan timings to neighbouring regions illustrates exactly what I have mentioned in the post. Religion is an outcome of the material realities around you. Islamic philsophy was sculpted around the social realities in West Asia and what is now Saudi Arabia, limited by geography. “God” never said any of those things. It is humans in those regions who claimed that God said those things.
Anyway, thanks for your comment.
This is a verse from the Quran:
2:184 (Fasting) for a fixed number of days; but if any of you is ill, or on a journey, the prescribed number (Should be made up) from days later. For those who can do it (With hardship), is a ransom, the feeding of one that is indigent. But he that will give more, of his own free will,- it is better for him. And it is better for you that ye fast, if ye only knew.
That means that they do not have to fast
Islam is a forgiving religion but you only choose to see what the people that do bad things and claim to be Muslims.
Read more about the subject before writing.
Ignorance spreads lies.
Thanks for commenting Assem.
I do know about the exceptions made. And I also do know of the scriptures that talk about love, compassion, peace and all that within Islam. I’m not one who judges a religion (or anything else for that matter) by making a straw-man out of the bad apples.
I don’t have problems with Muslims and have many who are close friends of mine. I only critique the concept of organised religion.
This post was only to point out towards the dialectic-material properties of the origin of religion, in this case, Islam. I think you missed this aspect of my post.
You are right. Ignorance was disliked by Prophet Mohammed (Peace be on him) as well. Anything that was prescribed by God for mankind was for the wellbeing of the mankind. God is not the beneficary. It is not meant to punish the mankind.. be it prayer or fasting. So, it can be flexible as long as the purpose is served. God is kind to mankind.
The problem is, most people tend to forget the miracles of his/her own birth process– born out of tiny invisible microsocopic cells. So, it is likely that these ignorants will comment whatever little they are presumed to know. After all a programme and a programmer can not be equally intelligent.
Thanks for commenting Rashid.
The process of birth is not a miracle and is well explained and understood by science. The word miracle is used for occurances that man cannot explain and hence ignorantly proclaims that some “higher supernatural power” is involved.
You say that God is kind to mankind. My question is, how do you know what God wants and does not want? I would presume that you know about God from the Koran. And who or what makes the Koran a document that is accurate and indeed a “revelation” of God himself? Well, you would believe it is because everyone says so, and oh, it’s written so in the Koran. That, my dear friend, is circular reasoning.
Here are two links that might interest you: http://bigotblog.wordpress.com/2009/08/15/spot-the-bloody-difference/ and
http://www.thejesusmyth.com/the-koran-exposed.htm
Thank you.
Acctually I live in Tromsø.. We are about 1000 muslims here.. We adjust our prayers after the nearest city with a sunset/sunrise.. :) Oslo is kind of far away… Now, Ramadan is coming, and on the first day sunrise is around 0400, and sunset around 2130:)
That’s good information, Hina. Thanks for commenting! :)
funnily enough…I was thinking about the same thing a few days ago.
good post though…I was expecting the comments to be full of hate and vinegar but turns out you got a good dialogue going…keep it up..
Hi Mohammed,
I expected a lot of hateful comments too!
Given I do not moderate any comment, it’s surprising this is all I got!
What’s wrong with remaining in your homeland? Worship in Allah’s land?
Yes but that doesn’t solve anything. How about not praying at all and instead using that time for some constructive work? Or if they don’t swing in that direction, how about just have some beer and chill the f**k out?